Who Should NOT Use Shopify (And What to Use Instead)
Shopify is the default e-commerce platform for a reason — it's powerful, reliable, and easy to use. It also starts at $39/month with no free tier, charges transaction fees if you don't use Shopify Payments, and adds up fast with apps and themes. Here's when to skip it.
The Quick Version
Shopify is built for businesses selling physical products who want an all-in-one store with payments, shipping, and inventory. If you're selling digital products, have fewer than 10 products, or are building courses, Shopify adds cost and complexity you don't need. The Basic plan starts at $39/month with a 2% transaction fee if not using Shopify Payments.
1. Selling Digital Products (PDFs, Templates, Downloads)
Shopify Basic at $39/month is designed for physical product stores with shipping, inventory, and fulfillment features. If you're selling a $29 PDF template or a $99 design kit, you're paying $468/year in platform fees before you sell a single unit. Plus potential transaction fees of 2% on Basic if not using Shopify Payments.
Gumroad charges $0/month and takes 10% + $0.50 per sale (plus payment processing). Lemon Squeezy charges $0/month and takes 5% + $0.50 per sale. Both handle global tax compliance, delivery, and checkout without monthly fees. You only pay when you sell.
Use Instead
- Gumroad — $0/month. 10% + $0.50 per sale (+ ~2.9% + $0.30 payment processing). Instant delivery, pay-what-you-want, memberships. Simplest possible digital storefront. See Gumroad review
- Lemon Squeezy — $0/month (Fresh plan). 5% + $0.50 per transaction. Handles global tax as merchant of record. Built specifically for software and digital products. Acquired by Stripe. See Lemon Squeezy review
| Platform | Monthly Fee | Per-Sale Fee | Tax Handling |
|---|---|---|---|
| Shopify Basic | $39/mo | 2% (or 0% with Shopify Payments) | Manual / app required |
| Gumroad | $0 | 10% + $0.50 + processing | Automatic (included) |
| Lemon Squeezy | $0 | 5% + $0.50 | Automatic (merchant of record) |
2. Selling Fewer Than 10 Products
If you have 3–10 products — a few physical items, some merch, or a small collection — Shopify's inventory management, shipping calculators, and multi-channel selling are features you'll barely use. You're paying $39/month for infrastructure designed for stores with hundreds of SKUs.
Carrd Pro Standard at $19/year ($1.58/month) lets you build a one-page site with embedded Stripe payment buttons. That's a 96% cost reduction compared to Shopify. You lose the full storefront experience but gain simplicity and savings that make sense for a tiny catalog.
Use Instead
- Carrd Pro Standard — $19/year ($1.58/month). Custom domain, forms, embeds, payments via Stripe. Perfect for a small product catalog on a single page. See Carrd review
- Squarespace Core — $36/month ($24/month annual). Beautiful templates, unlimited products, 0% transaction fee. A full website builder with built-in commerce. See Squarespace review
3. Course Creators and Membership Sellers
Shopify was built for product commerce, not content commerce. Selling online courses on Shopify requires third-party apps (like Thinkific or Teachable integrations), each adding $30–$100/month on top of your Shopify subscription. The total stack cost for course selling on Shopify can easily hit $100–$200/month.
Dedicated course platforms like Teachable and Kajabi include course hosting, student management, payment processing, and community features in one package. Gumroad handles course-like products (video bundles, membership access) with zero monthly fees. The tools built for this use case are cheaper and better than bolting course features onto Shopify.
Use Instead
- Gumroad — $0/month. Sell digital products, memberships, and subscription access. 10% + $0.50 per sale. No course-specific features, but handles content delivery for digital bundles. See Gumroad review
- Lemon Squeezy — $0/month. 5% + $0.50 per transaction. License key management, subscription billing, and digital delivery built-in. Better for SaaS-style access models. See Lemon Squeezy review
4. Bootstrapped Sellers Watching Every Dollar
Shopify's real cost isn't just $39/month. Paid apps average $20–$50/month each (most stores use 3–6 apps). Premium themes cost $180–$350 one-time. Transaction fees add 2% on the Basic plan if you're not using Shopify Payments. A realistic first-year cost is $800–$2,000+ depending on apps and theme choices.
Squarespace Basic at $25/month ($16/month annual) includes a website builder, unlimited bandwidth and storage, and basic commerce with a 2% transaction fee. No app marketplace to drain your wallet. WooCommerce (free plugin) on a $7–$15/month host gives you maximum control with lower ongoing costs, though setup is more complex.
Use Instead
- Squarespace Basic — $25/month ($16/month annual). Beautiful templates, unlimited bandwidth, built-in commerce. No app marketplace means no surprise costs. See Squarespace review
The Exception: When Shopify IS the Right Choice
Shopify is the right choice for businesses selling physical products who need a scalable, all-in-one e-commerce platform with payment processing, shipping, inventory management, and multi-channel selling.
If you're shipping physical goods, need inventory tracking across channels (Amazon, Instagram, retail POS), and want a platform that scales from 10 products to 10,000, Shopify's ecosystem is unmatched. The 8,000+ app marketplace, Shopify Payments (removing transaction fees), and shipping discounts up to 77% on the Basic plan make it genuinely the best platform for serious e-commerce operations.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does Shopify have a free tier?
No. Shopify offers a 3-day free trial, then $1/month for the first 3 months. After that, Basic is $39/month, Shopify is $105/month, and Advanced is $399/month.
What are Shopify's transaction fees?
If you use Shopify Payments: 0% transaction fee (just standard credit card processing). If you use a third-party payment gateway: 2% on Basic, 1% on Shopify, 0.6% on Advanced. This is on top of your payment processor's fees.
Can I sell digital products on Shopify?
Yes, with apps like Digital Downloads (free from Shopify) or third-party apps. But the experience is bolted on, not native. Gumroad and Lemon Squeezy are built specifically for digital product delivery and are cheaper.
How much do Shopify apps really cost?
Most stores use 3–6 paid apps. Common apps (reviews, email, upsells, SEO) range from $10–$50/month each. App costs of $50–$200/month on top of the platform fee are typical for established stores.
Explore Further on Sasanova
Comparisons