Basecamp
37signals LLC
7.5
Overall Score / 10
Asana
Asana Inc.
6.6
Overall Score / 10
Our Verdict
Choose Basecamp if:
- —You want simplicity and built-in async communication
- —Your team is small and values calm, opinionated workflows
- —You prefer flat-rate pricing without feature gating
Choose Asana if:
- —You need timelines, Gantt charts, and portfolio tracking
- —You need workflow automations and custom rules
- —You have large teams with complex project structures
The biggest difference: Basecamp is an opinionated, all-in-one tool with built-in group chat and message boards; Asana is a dedicated PM tool with advanced views and automations
Side-by-Side Comparison
| Criteria | Basecamp | Asana |
|---|---|---|
| Cheapest Paid Plan | $15/mo (Basecamp)Source: 37signals LLC pricing page → | $13.49/mo (Starter)Source: Asana Inc. pricing page → |
| Free Tier | Yes Personal use, 1 user, limited projects | Yes Up to 2 users, unlimited tasks and projects, list and board views only |
| Value for Money | 7 | 6 |
| Ease of Use | 9 | 8 |
| Feature Power | 5 | 7 |
| Setup Ease | 9 | 8 |
| Migration Ease | 7 | 5 |
| Transparency | 9 | 6 |
| Deployment | cloud | cloud |
| API Available | Yes | Yes |
| Platforms | Web, Mac, Windows, iOS, Android | Web, Mac, Windows, iOS, Android |
| Compliance | GDPR, SOC 2 Type II | SOC 2 Type II, GDPR, ISO 27001 |
Feature Comparison
Feature Comparison Matrix
21 features compared · 20 differences
| Feature | Basecamp | Asana |
|---|---|---|
| Core | ||
| Approvals | None | Full |
| Automatic notifications | Full | None |
| Board view | None | Full |
| Calendar | None | Full |
| Campfires (group chat) | Full | None |
| Card table (kanban) | Full | None |
| Check-ins | Full | None |
| Docs & files | Full | None |
| Forms | None | Full |
| Goals | None | Full |
| Hill charts | Full | None |
| List view | None | Full |
| Message boards | Full | None |
| Portfolios | None | Full |
| Schedules | Full | None |
| Tasks and subtasks | None | Full |
| Timeline (Gantt) | None | Full |
| To-do lists | Full | None |
| Advanced | ||
| Reporting | None | Full |
| Workflow builder | None | Full |
| Integrations | ||
| API Access | Full | Full |
Pricing Comparison
Basecamp Pricing
Personal use, 1 user, limited projects
All features, unlimited projects, 500GB storage
Unlimited users, 5TB storage, priority support, 1:1 onboarding
Asana Pricing
Up to 2 users, unlimited tasks/projects, basic views
Timeline, workflow builder, forms, unlimited dashboards
Portfolios, goals, custom rules, approvals, proofing
SAML, data loss prevention, custom branding, audit logs
Who Should Choose Which?
Who should choose Basecamp
Best for
- Small teams that value simplicity over power features
- Remote teams wanting async-first communication
- Organizations tired of complex project management tools
Avoid if
- You need Gantt charts, timelines, or resource planning
- You need deep integrations and automations
- You need per-task custom fields and advanced reporting
Who should choose Asana
Best for
- Teams that want structured, opinionated project management
- Marketing and ops teams managing recurring workflows
- Organizations that value clean UI and ease of onboarding
Avoid if
- You need docs/wiki alongside project management
- You want maximum customization (ClickUp wins)
- You're a solo user (limited value on free tier)
Switching Guidance
Switching from Basecamp
Common triggers to leave:
- •Need advanced project views (timeline, Gantt)
- •Need custom fields and reporting
- •Need deeper integrations
Potential blockers:
- •Accumulated message boards and discussions
- •Team habits built around Basecamp's workflow
- •Simple data model is easy to export
Switching from Asana
Common triggers to leave:
- •Need docs/wiki features
- •Need more customization
- •Pricing for large teams
Potential blockers:
- •Established workflows
- •Goal/portfolio tracking
- •Team habits
Try Basecamp
Start free — no credit card required
Try Asana
Start free — no credit card required